Let me preface this by saying that while I fancy myself an 'intellectual' person who doesn't piddle in the pedestrian dealings of the common man....thats all bullshit. I am not hung up on being politically correct all the time-- if something is funny I laugh. I believe we can laugh at ourselves, when its meant in jest; laughing at pain and hard ache is something different, of course.
Borat played on a fine line of offensive and funny. I laughed, but wasn't sure if I should have. I felt the same for much of Bruno. Bruno, like Borat, is funny because it captures candid reactions from people that are facing their 'worst fears' in social stereotypes. Borat was the inappropriate, obtuse, and rude 'tourist'. We aren't supposed to laugh at tourists, because they are supposed to be incredulously well-intentioned. Borat forced people into a corner, where they didn't know how to react. Often this was awkward and funny. If reality television has taught us anything, it's that we love watching people squirm. We laugh at embarrassing situations... I'm not really sure if this is good or not-- but I can't deny that I find it entertaining. Although I find masturabation entertaining too... I guess they are both self-serving.
Bruno is the homophobes worst nightmare. Not only is he effeminate, but he is relentless and uncaring of the clear discomfort of his audience: he calls the angry army sargeant a 'she', he tells the ex-gay minister he has nice 'blow job lips', he makes very obvious advances (and strips) in front of conservative presidential hopeful Ron Paul. He is not just gay-- he is inappropriate and aggressive. I am pretty sure that even I, as a gay person, would be uncomfortable in a room with Bruno. So I don't think you can construe Bruno as making fun of gay people-- I think its so over the top that normal people understand that "Brunos" don't exist. And if they do-- its not their homosexuality that is discomforting its just their plain disregard for other people's attitudes, comfort, and personal space.
So yes, after the first fifteen minutes, I laughed. I laughed a lot, and had to cover my eyes at some points because it was so uncomfortable to watch: he goes hunting with the straightest southern guys in Alabama and tries twice to get into one of their tents nude; he calls hotel staff into his room to unlock he and his 'sex slave' who are hand-cuffed and bound in leather with dildos- because they can't find the key; he gets a hollywood agent to setup a meeting with a top network exec to focus group a 'pilot' that is nothing but him dancing and making fun of Jamie-Lynn Spear's baby fetus.

The climax of the movie is one of the most awkward, embarrassing, and unfortunately real scenes I have seen. Bruno decides he wants to become straight and after 8 months of 'therapy' hosts a 'cage fighting' event with $1 beers (typical homophobic red-neck lure, see poster picture). Then he riles the audience up for fighting by stripping girls down to bikinis. He goes on a diatribe about how straight he is, and then someone calls him a 'fag' from the audience. He invites the heckler into the ring. It's another character from the movie who had a falling out with Bruno earlier. In the ring, they fake fight a few minutes ending in a staring match, and then the staring turns into obvious sexual tension, and they kiss. The kissing escalates into very homo-erotic humping, making out, etc. The crowd goes ballistic-- they hurl beers at them, at one point a chair thrown into the ring-- it is absolute mayhem. I just don't know how the police were able to control this without someone getting killed. I have never seen such a riot. It was like a car wreck-- I didn't want to watch, I didn't want to laugh-- but I couldn't take my eyes away. If nothing else, Sacha Baron Cohen has enormous balls.
So after typing this, I'm not sure how I really feel about the movie. I'm glad I saw it- I definitely laughed really hard. I'm not sure how I feel about the 'ethics' of the movie, or if its good that it exists out there. Or whether it would be better/worse to live in a world where this weren't funny. More questions than answers... however, I suppose this is the best result of reflecting on things.
What are your thoughts?
Much Love,
Steve
11 comments:
What are my thoughts? ...I'm not entirely sure. lol
'Bruno' appeared on an Australian talkshow just over a week ago. I knew that the character existed and everything, but i hadn't actually seen him in action. So i entered the experience thinking that i would see a character that was over-the-top gay, poking fun at gay people.
I ended up laughing my ass off. There were some really funny things that i lol'd at. I was pleasantly surprised i guess.
While it was all pretty funny, i did have this kind of... guilty feeling afterwards. Idk it's hard to 'splain. On one hand, i was laughing at a character that was so extremely over-the-top it was funny, and on the other hand, well, he's gay and the joke was on him.
So yah, the more... less-learned viewers would be laughing at what they saw as just a gay person, when in fact we're... very different to that (mostly). :P
Idk. It's all very complicated. Maybe it's not worth devoting much thought to. :P
love
Fair enough- I agree there are certainly more important things to think about...but I'm short on blog ideas, gimme a break :-)
I totally agree with-- I think 'normal' people understand that laughing at Bruno isn't making fun of gay people, and it is probably easy for 'dumb' people to think that Bruno is just an average gay guy--and 'oh, look how funny gay people are'.
So yep... complicated is a good word for it.
Thanks for commentin' though and makin me feel all special and such :-)
Much Love,
Steve
I just watched the interview on Rove and, honestly, did not even crack a smile. Maybe it's due to my actually being gay but I didn't find him one bit believable as either a gay person or a real person (i.e., someone not playing a character). Beyond that, I just didn't find anything he said all that funny.
Full disclosure: I hated Borat. He was awful to nice people and let people who deserved abuse off the hook easy. I mean, Alan Keyes came across as not a bad guy when he's vitriolically anti-gay, even to the point of disowning his own daughter for being a lesbian.
personally I can't wait to see the movie - I think SBC is comic genius and have watched him going back to the Ali G days when I lived in London. Just watch him in Talladega Nights or hear his voice as King Julian in Madagascar and you will see how awesome he is. He's not gay BTW - he's married with a daughter (ok, how stupid was that comment coming from me?). He was also raised as an ultra-Orthodox Jew. Yes - the joke is on him as well as everyone around him - I think that's what creates the magic.
@Mr. HCI - Perhaps it was our Aussie humour? lol
@Mr HCI
I think this is probably the most polarizing type of entertainment, which I guess is why its interesting to me. In fairness, I don't think Sacha BC is trying to come across as a believable person (gay or otherwise). I agree- I don't see how anyone could believe that a Bruno really exists.
I suppose there were some 'nice' people that Borat embarrassed. I think we should distinguish nice from well-intentioned-- the latter doesn't imply the former. There are plenty of southern folk who are well-intentioned but aren't nice.
I'm not trying to challenge your opinion at all-- Im still not really sure if I 'should' feel bad or not for laughing... but its interesting none the less.
Steve
I saw 'Brüno' only on The Tonight Show with Conan O'Brien and on Rove and I laughed my ass of (though the punch lines were pretty identical).
I think it's clear to everybody that gays are not that way. Brüno is a caricature of gay clichés that are in the heads of people out there. By playing this role so over the top SBC damasks them. With the hopeful effect that nobody expects us any longer to act like this. Honestly, I reckon he does us a big favour.
I liked the interview sequences much more than the extracts from the film. I don't think I will see the film in the cinema, but wait till it's shown on a long-haul or the telly.
I won't be going to see it in the cinema. I'll wait till it's on television so i can put my head under the covers if i have the need. :P
Hokay,
Bruno was funny. No doubt in my mind.
However,
If was funny on multiple levels.
The most obvious level would be the crude and juvenile.....potty humor? that takes place over the majority of the film. this would be the material that hardcore conservatives and fundametalists object to (compare to language and content in south park and the insane amount of the n-bomb in Twain's classic "huck finn").
And no doubt, that is what the majority of the people in the theatre laughed at.
HOWEVER
As is the case in south park and huck finn, Bruno is not about language...or being attacked by dildos....... or having an exercise bike-powered super anal dildo shoved into your ass over and over............ or putting your black baby with the ethnically correct name of OJ onto a cross....
umm.....where was I?
Oh yea...
Its not about the potty humour, its about the underlying message.
Bruno is a social commentary on America, and how ridiculously homophobic the land of the free really is, Just as huck finn was a commentary on racist america and south park tackles American society in general.
And while I did laugh at Bruno
There were some parts I couldn't laugh at.
Ron Paul screaming this guy is a QUEER.
Cage match rednecks going insane and crying over gay love.
The gay converters; both of them.
My hope is that someday people will look at bruno as they look at Huck finn. A brilliant hidden social commentary that can accurately reflect the thoughts and actions of the people at the time with a bitingly sarcastic and disgusted tone.
SBC, I applaud you
We need more hidden genius in our slowly degrading society.
Thanks for all your hard work.
@jake
good analysis-- I agree that the wrestling match crowd reactions were an unfortunate illustration of social mores in southern America.
P.S. your music taste rocks!! every band on your profile made me more and more excited. Maybe its just a location thing or that I don't have good friends-- but I cannot find many people that really share my music tastes or even a whole subset of my preferences. Ergo, I had no one to go to MGMT with when they came here. Although I slacked and it was sold out anyways...
Much Love,
STeve
Thanks :) http://blip.fm/Jakearam there is my personal channel.
Post a Comment